ToolScore
VPN 4 min read

A VPN's Real Price Is Year 3

+287% — NordVPN Basic, intro to renewal the number that matters here

By Stan K.

The intro price on a VPN landing page is bait. NordVPN Basic renews at $11.59/mo after a $2.99 intro, Complete at $18.29, Proton VPN Plus at $6.99. Every current plan's 3-year total, computed from official pricing pages — the only number worth comparing.

VPN pricing pages are built around the number you’ll pay first and quiet about the number you’ll pay forever. The intro rate is a customer-acquisition cost the vendor eats; the renewal is the product. Every figure below was checked on the providers’ official pricing pages on 2026-11-13, then stretched over a common 36-month horizon — intro term plus renewal months — because that is the only way two plans with different term lengths can be compared at all. The landing page will never show you this table.

The intro is bait — here is the bill

PlanIntroRenewalJump3-year total
NordVPN Basic$2.99/mo ($80.73 for 27 months)$11.59/mo ($139.08/yr)+287%$185.04
NordVPN Complete$3.99/mo ($107.73 for 27 months)$18.29/mo ($219.48/yr)+358%$272.34
NordVPN Prime$6.99/mo ($188.73 for 27 months)$296.28/yr+324%$410.94
Proton VPN Plus$2.99/mo ($35.88 for the first 12 months)$6.99/mo ($83.88/yr)+134%$155.64
Proton Unlimited$6.49/mo ($77.88 per 12-month cycle)$119.88/yr+54%~$275.64
Mullvad€5/mo flat€5/mo (€60/yr) — unchanged0%€180
PIA (3-year plan)$81.20 total for 36 months$81.20 every 3 years0%$81.20
The same 36 months of VPN (USD plans)
NordVPN Prime $410.94
Proton Unlimited ~$275.64
NordVPN Complete $272.34
NordVPN Basic $185.04
Proton VPN Plus $155.64
PIA (3-year plan) $81.20

Two reading notes. The jump is computed on the monthly basis, and intro rates move daily — NordVPN Basic’s intro has been seen at $2.99–3.49, which makes the same renewal a +232–287% jump. Anchor on the renewal column: it is the stable number, and it is the bill.

$410.94 vs $81.20the same 36 months of VPN

NordVPN Prime costs $410.94 over three years — more than five times PIA’s $81.20, and more than double NordVPN’s own Basic tier ($185.04), for the same core VPN plus bundle features. Mullvad’s flat €180 lands mid-board with a 0% jump. None of this spread is visible before you click “buy”.

The two zeros

Only two providers on the board charge year 3 exactly like year 1. Mullvad does it by design: one price, €5 including VAT, the same whether you buy one month or three years. PIA does it as of today’s check: the 3-year plan costs $81.20 total and autorenews at the same $81.20 every 3 years. The famous “PIA renewal jump” story was true of past pricing; the current page is clean, and we report both halves of that sentence. Surfshark doesn’t make the table at all — its renewal price isn’t published, so no total is computable (that silence is dissected in VPN Renewal Traps, Verified).

The standard move: never pay year 3

The renewal only bites customers who auto-renew. The standard move, practiced by everyone who reads pricing pages for fun: cancel before the intro term ends, then buy a new promo — same vendor or a competitor, since intro prices exist to be churned. Auto-renewing a 27-month NordVPN intro costs $139.08–296.28/yr; nobody who re-buys pays that. If you are the set-and-forget type who will not calendar a cancellation, the flat-price plans are the only honest option — the churn strategy has a cost in attention, and that is a real cost.

The full tables — jurisdiction, audits, free tiers, and no speed claims we can’t measure — live in the VPN hub. And if your actual job is “operate US accounts”, a VPN may be the wrong tool entirely: renting a real US phone buys things no VPN sells.

To model your own pick before checkout, the free VPN 3-year price calculator computes the 36-month total and the real $/month — intro term plus renewal, per plan.

Numbers change — the math doesn't
Token prices and plan limits shift monthly; the structural arguments in this guide age slowly. For current per-tool numbers see the live rankings.