Signal
Signal Foundation / Signal Messenger LLC · messaging · reviewed by Stan K. · Source: data snapshot · data as of 2026-11-13
Everything E2EE by default — text and voice from the same default, sealed sender, and a subpoena that produces exactly two dates. The privacy floor every other app in this comparison is measured against.
#1 of 7 in Messaging
ToolScore breakdown — why 68/100
10 criteria × 10 points. Low pillars are visible on purpose — that's the point of a score you can audit. Methodology →
What it does well
- ▸Everything is E2EE by default — text and voice share the same default, no settings to find
- ▸A subpoena produces exactly two facts: the date the account was registered and the last date of connectivity (signal.org/bigbrother)
- ▸Sealed Sender hides who messages whom “whenever possible” (signal.org/blog/sealed-sender)
- ▸No cloud backup means no backup trap: the archive cannot be escrowed anywhere because it does not exist
- ▸501(c)(3) nonprofit since 2018, funded by donations — never VC
Where it costs you
- ▸No cloud backup exists at all — only local device-to-device transfer
- ▸No community features — the limit that rules it out for running a large community (see Discord/Slack in the hub)
- ▸Not self-hostable: published server code is auditable, not deployable
- ▸The Foundation's $50,000,000 from Brian Acton is an interest-free loan due 28 February 2068 — no official source has ever said it was forgiven
Hidden traps — the stuff the pricing page doesn't say
The Foundation's initial $50,000,000 from Brian Acton is an interest-free loan due 28 February 2068. Media claims that it was forgiven exist — Signal hasn't said so. President is Meredith Whittaker (since September 2022); Acton is Executive Chairman of the Foundation and CEO of Signal Messenger LLC.
Signal has no cloud backup to misuse, only a local device-to-device transfer. Lose the device before the transfer and the history is gone; the privacy posture and the backup gap are the same design decision.
The published server code makes the no-logs posture auditable, but there is no self-host path. If “own the server, own the retention” is your requirement, that exit is Matrix, not Signal.
Know the limits before you pay: read the traps above, then decide with eyes open.
Visit official siteAffiliate link where available — never affects the score.
- official Signal — the only information we can produce (official, checked 2026-11-13) verified
- official Sealed Sender — hiding who messages whom (official) verified
- official Signal donations / Foundation facts (official) verified
Data as of 2026-11-13. Prices and limits change monthly — report anything stale. How we verify: methodology.
Closest alternatives
The structural exit: unlimited history you own, federation and E2EE on your own server — the backup
$0 for the 500-member community that bills $4,375/mo on Slack Pro, with unlimited free history — the
Free at 200,000-member scale with unlimited cloud history and 2GB files — but the default cloud chat
Signal review
In-depth analysis · last updated 2026-11-13
The privacy floor
Signal is the app the rest of this comparison is measured against, and the reason is a single design fact: everything is end-to-end encrypted by default — text and voice share the same default, with no setting to find and no opt-in to miss. A subpoena produces exactly two facts: the date the account was registered and the last date of connectivity (signal.org/bigbrother). Sealed Sender goes one step further and hides who messages whom “whenever possible” — the metadata ledger every other app in the hub keeps simply does not accumulate here.
No backup trap, because there is no backup
The hub's quiet killer — default backups handing the archive to Google/Apple — cannot exist in Signal, because Signal has no cloud backup at all. The only path is a local device-to-device transfer. That is the strongest possible version of the default-posture argument, and simultaneously a real limit: no cloud restore, and no community features — the two honest limits the hub attaches to Signal's name.
Funding: the asterisk that is smaller than it looks
Signal is a 501(c)(3) nonprofit since 2018 (Tax ID 82-4506840), funded by donations — never VC. The Foundation's initial $50,000,000 from Brian Acton is an interest-free loan due 28 February 2068; no official source has ever said it was forgiven, and we don't publish what we haven't checked. Meredith Whittaker has been President since September 2022; Acton is Executive Chairman of the Foundation and CEO of Signal Messenger LLC.
How the pillars land
Price/Value 10: $0, donation-funded, no paid tiers to price-check. E2EE & metadata 10: E2EE everywhere by default, sealed sender, and the two-fact subpoena — the ceiling of this pillar. Transparency 10: nothing to hide because nothing is sold. Real limits 6: the no-backup/no-community-features ceiling is real and documented. Federation/self-host 3: published server code makes the posture auditable, but there is no self-host path. Feature set 6 and Track record 8 follow from the same facts. Platforms & sync, Ease of use and Support & docs sit at the neutral 5 — none of the three was verifiable from this snapshot's official pages.
Verdict — 68/100, PRIVACY FLOOR
If the question is “which app is encrypted without touching a setting — backups included”, Signal is the answer and the benchmark. Accept the feature ceiling (no cloud backup, no community features) as the price of the posture: the two are the same design decision.