ToolScore

StartMail

StartMail · email privacy · reviewed by Stan K. · Source: data snapshot · data as of 2026-11-13

Unlimited aliases with sending — burner addresses included — the encrypted inbox that behaves like an alias service.

#6 of 10 in Email Privacy

Get StartMail
Real price
$4.99/mo
subscription
Free tier
No
Personal: $4.99/mo annual ($59.88/yr) or $6.99 billed monthly — the priciest lead entry among the encrypted pr
Limits
8.0/10
$4.99/mo annual ($59.88/yr) · $6.99 monthly · Business $6.99/mo annual
Verdict
GOOD
Personal: 20GB storage, unlimited aliases including burner addresses, 1 custom domain, sending cap — (not publ

ToolScore breakdown — why 71/100

Price / Value
7.0
Real limits (storage · caps · bandwidth)
8.0
Clients & access (IMAP, apps)
6.0
Metadata posture
8.0
Custom domains
7.0
Feature set (aliases, PGP)
9.0
Track record
7.0
Ease of use
7.0
Pricing transparency
7.0
Support & docs
5.0

10 criteria × 10 points. Low pillars are visible on purpose — that's the point of a score you can audit. Methodology →

What it does well

  • ▸Unlimited aliases with sending, burner addresses included — the encrypted inbox that behaves like an alias service
  • ▸Custom-domain addresses do send/receive
  • ▸Password-protected variant covers the subject for encrypted external mail — a step beyond body-only PGP
  • ▸At-rest encryption is unconditional in our subject matrix ('Encrypted', not conditional)
  • ▸Business tier scales to unlimited custom domains (scored 73 in our hub)

Where it costs you

  • ▸$4.99/mo annual ($6.99 monthly) is the most expensive lead entry in the encrypted table — €3 buys 20GB at Tuta or 30GB at Mailbox.org
  • ▸Business monthly billing is not plainly published (~$10.99 in one render; 'Save $24' math implies $8.99)
  • ▸'Reply from alias' is not spelled out on the page
  • ▸Sending cap and IMAP details stayed unverifiable from official pages

Hidden traps — the stuff the pricing page doesn't say

medium riskBusiness monthly billing is not plainly published

Only the annual $6.99/mo ($83.88/yr) is quotable. The monthly price rendered as ~$10.99 in one pass while the 'Save $24' arithmetic implies $8.99 — a $2 spread on the same page's own math. Whatever you budget, budget it annually.

medium risk'Reply from alias' is not spelled out

The page documents that custom-domain addresses do send/receive, but the alias-reply flow is never spelled out. Unlimited aliases with sending is the headline; the exact reply behavior is homework left to the buyer.

low riskCaps and IMAP stayed unverifiable

StartMail's sending cap and IMAP details could not be verified from official pages in our check — the cells stay '—' until published, so the real limits of the 'unlimited' alias flow are unknown.

Try StartMail

Know the limits before you pay: read the traps above, then decide with eyes open.

Visit official site

Affiliate link where available — never affects the score.

What the advertised price hides
Personal: $4.99/mo annual ($59.88/yr) or $6.99 billed monthly — the priciest lead entry among the encrypted providers. Business (scored 73 in our hub): $6.99/mo annual ($83.88/yr); the monthly price is not plainly published (~$10.99 in one render; 'Save $24' arithmetic implies $8.99) — annual is the only quotable number.
Sources & freshness

Data as of 2026-11-13. Prices and limits change monthly — report anything stale. How we verify: methodology.

Closest alternatives

StartMail review

In-depth analysis · last updated 2026-11-13

An encrypted inbox wearing an alias service's clothes

StartMail's pitch collapses two products into one: an encrypted mailbox with unlimited aliases — burner addresses included — that can send, not just receive. Our hub calls it "the encrypted inbox that behaves like an alias service": where Proton wants you to bolt SimpleLogin on top and Mailbox.org meters you to a hundred aliases, StartMail ships the identity layer inside the subscription.

The economics

Personal is $4.99/mo annual ($59.88/yr) or $6.99 monthly — the priciest lead entry in the encrypted table: Tuta and Mailbox.org both ask €3 for comparable-or-more storage. Business (scored 73 in our hub, two points above Personal) is $6.99/mo annual ($83.88/yr) for 30GB, unlimited aliases and unlimited custom domains — but its monthly price is not plainly published: one render showed ~$10.99 while the page's own 'Save $24' arithmetic implies $8.99. Annual is the only quotable number on either tier.

Real limits

Personal gives 20GB, unlimited aliases including burners, and 1 custom domain whose addresses do send and receive. What the page does not spell out: whether and how 'reply from alias' works. The sending cap stayed "—" in our check, so the practical ceiling of all that alias sending is unknown — the 'unlimited' is only as good as the unpublished limits behind it.

How the pillars land

Feature set 9: unlimited aliases + burners + sending is the strongest identity tooling on a lead tier here. Real limits 8: 20GB and the unlimited-alias headline are published, the cap is not. Metadata posture 8: body-only subject internally, a password-protected variant covering the subject for encrypted external mail, and an unconditional 'Encrypted' at rest. Custom domains 7: one on Personal — unlimited exists, but only on Business. Price/Value 7: the most expensive entry for the least published substance. Pricing transparency 7: Personal's prices are clean; the vendor's Business page muddies the water. Clients & access 6, neutral: IMAP stayed unverifiable from official pages. Support & docs sits at the neutral 5 — nothing support-related was verifiable from the official pages in this snapshot.

Verdict — GOOD, 71/100

Pick StartMail when aliases-with-sending matter more than storage per dollar: one subscription instead of inbox-plus-alias-service, burners included. If you'd rather have the published caps and the Bridge (Proton) or the subject-line E2E (Tuta) at a lower entry price, the competition sells both.

From the insights