Email Aliases: What We Learned Setting Ours Up
10 aliases, $0, replies included the number that matters here
By Stan K.
We run ToolScore on a Proton inbox with an alias layer in front — SimpleLogin Free's 10 aliases with replies included are the best value we verified. The traps that ruled others out: Addy.io's 10MB/month bandwidth meter, Firefox Relay's vanished prices and 3-month reply window, DuckDuckGo's SPF catch.
Honesty first: this is not a decade of alias wisdom. It’s the setup we actually run at ToolScore, plus the numbers we verified against official pages on 2026-11-13 while building it. The short version — a Proton inbox with aliases in front of it — matches the pattern Proton itself chose when it bought SimpleLogin in 2022: encrypted inbox + alias layer, in that order.
Our setup, honestly
Signups, newsletters and one-off downloads never touch the real address. On the Proton side that means hide-my-email aliases — Free includes 10. In front of it sits SimpleLogin Free, and after pricing everything in the category it remains the best value we can verify: 10 aliases, unlimited bandwidth, replies work out of the box, one destination mailbox, $0. The per-email cap is 25MB (their FAQ), which in practice means “normal mail”; the alias count is the real limit.
The detail that decided it: replies. An alias you can’t answer from is a one-way door — fine for newsletters, broken the first time a support thread expects an answer. SimpleLogin is the only free tier we verified where replies just work. And it’s downgrade-safe in writing: cancel Premium and the aliases you created keep forwarding normally; you just can’t create new ones past 10.
The traps that ruled the others out
Addy.io Free advertises unlimited standard aliases — over a 10MB monthly bandwidth meter. One attachment-heavy Tuesday can exhaust the month; one recipient; no replies on Free at all. The alias generator never stops; the pipe does. Paid fixes it: Lite is $12/yr with 100MB/month and 50 replies a day.
Firefox Relay we couldn’t price at all — as of 2026-11-13 the official page shows no prices and every button says “Join the Waitlist.” What is verified: Free is 5 masks with no reply; Premium lets you reply only within 3 months of receiving, cannot initiate a new thread at all, forwards nothing over 10MB, and never takes your own domain — one mozmail.com subdomain instead. DuckDuckGo Email Protection is genuinely free and unlimited — @duck.com addresses, tracker removal on every forward, replies that route through duck.com — but its SPF catch is disqualifying for anything on a custom domain: if your forwarding address sits on a unique domain without an SPF record, replies are simply “not supported.” There’s also no web dashboard — aliases live in the DDG browser’s Passwords menu or in per-email banners.
When to pay: the custom-domain rule
Ten aliases lasted us until the first project that needed a durable identity. That’s the honest upgrade trigger, and there’s exactly one rule worth the money: when an address has to outlive the service — invoices, a professional identity, a domain you control — move to your own domain with a catch-all, via SimpleLogin Premium at $36/yr. That buys unlimited aliases and domains, 5 subdomains, 50 directories, PGP encryption, and the reverse-alias that finally lets you initiate — not just reply — from an alias. If the inbox side needs upgrading too, the full per-year math is in The Real Cost of a Private Inbox; every service’s verified limits and bandwidth numbers are in the Email privacy hub.