The Real Cost of a Private Inbox
€12/yr — the cheapest real PGP stack the number that matters here
By Stan K.
Encrypted mail is quoted at EUR 1-9 per month, but the numbers that decide the bill are storage per year and the sending cap. Every verified 2026 price converted: Proton Free's 150/day where every recipient counts, the $2.49 promo that renews at $47.88/yr, Tuta at EUR 36/yr, and the EUR 12/yr cheapest real PGP stack.
Encrypted-email pricing pages sell a monthly sticker — €1 to €9 — and stay quiet about the two numbers that actually decide what a private inbox costs you: how much storage a year of billing buys, and how many messages a day you’re allowed to send. Every price below was verified against official pages on 2026-11-13, converted into a yearly bill, and paired with the cap that does the real limiting.
What a gigabyte of encrypted mail costs
The same arithmetic applied to every verified annual price:
| Provider / tier | Yearly bill | Storage | Per GB per year | The cap that limits you first |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Tuta Legend | €96 | 500GB | ≈€0.19 | 500GB you’ll likely never fill |
| Mailbox.org Standard | €36 | 30GB combined | €1.20 | — (no published cap) |
| Tuta Revolutionary | €36 | 20GB | €1.80 | Dynamic sending limits — no published number |
| StartMail Personal | $59.88 | 20GB | ≈$3.00 | — |
| Proton Mail Plus (renewal) | $47.88 | 15GB shared | ≈$3.19 | 100 recipients per email |
| Mailbox.org Light | €12 | 2GB | €6.00 | 3 aliases, no custom domain |
| CounterMail (12mo prepaid) | $49 | 4GB | $12.25 | Closed to new registrations |
Storage per euro swings roughly 60× between Tuta Legend and CounterMail — but storage is almost never the binding constraint on a private mailbox. Caps are.
The sending caps nobody prices
Proton is the only provider in this table that publishes hard sending numbers, and they’re the ones that bite: Free gets 150 messages per day and 50 per hour — and every recipient counts as a separate message. One send to a 10-person group burns 10 of the 150; a free account mailing a 15-person group exhausts its day in 10 sends. Paid lifts the per-email ceiling to 100 recipients; the paid daily cap is not published. Free also organizes you into 3 folders, 3 labels and 1 filter — the limits that bite long before 1GB of storage does.
Tuta publishes no numeric cap at all — limits are dynamic and decided server-side. Mailbox.org, StartMail and CounterMail stay silent on their official pages. An unpublished cap isn’t necessarily a small cap; it’s an unverifiable one, and we mark it ”—” rather than guess.
The stack, priced per year
Private email is rarely one product — it’s an inbox plus an alias layer. Priced per year:
- Minimum viable PGP stack: €12/yr. Mailbox.org Light (€1/mo, annual billing only) gives you 2GB and full OpenPGP — Guard, Mailvelope, their own HKPS key server — even at the bottom tier. Pair it with SimpleLogin Free (10 aliases, unlimited bandwidth, replies work, $0) and the entire privacy stack costs one euro a month.
- Comfortable stack: $65.88 the first year, $83.88 after. Proton Mail Plus ($2.49/mo promo = $29.88 year one) plus SimpleLogin Premium ($36/yr, unlimited aliases and domains). Budget the renewal, not the promo.
$29.88 → $47.88Proton Mail Plus: year one vs. every year after
The $2.49/mo rate is a first-year promo; the renewal is $47.88/yr ($3.99/mo), and monthly billing is $4.99. A three-year Plus commitment really costs $29.88 + $47.88 + $47.88 = $125.64 — a total the pricing page never shows.
What the caps don’t tell you — which metadata survives encryption no matter what you pay — is covered in Your Encrypted Email Leaks Its Subject Line. The alias half of the stack, and the bandwidth traps hiding under “unlimited alias” headlines, is in Email Aliases: What We Learned Setting Ours Up. And if your threat model is spam rather than surveillance, Gmail + Aliases Is Enough makes the case for keeping the wallet closed. The full verified tables live in the Email privacy hub.
To price your own stack — 1 to 10 users, promo vs renewal — the free email stack calculator does the arithmetic for you.