Gmail + Aliases Is Enough
$0 alias layer, €1 escape hatch the number that matters here
By Stan K.
If the threat is spam and marketing mail — not the state — DuckDuckGo's free unlimited aliases plus your existing inbox's filters do the job for $0. The two cases where the paid stack earns its price (a professional domain, content-sensitive correspondence), and the EUR 1/month escape hatch when you outgrow free.
Not every inbox needs to be private. The honest first question in email privacy is a threat model, and for most people the answer is uncomfortable for the industry: if what you’re escaping is spam, marketing lists and the occasional data broker — not a state actor, not a subpoena — your existing Gmail plus a free alias layer already covers you. Here is when that’s true, and when it isn’t.
The threat model Gmail survives
The free tool that does the alias job is DuckDuckGo Email Protection: unlimited @duck.com addresses, $0, no paid tier, tracker removal on every forward, and replies that route back through duck.com so they just work. Generate one alias per sender, filter them into labels in your existing inbox, and kill the alias the first time it leaks. For newsletter signups, one-off shops and “enter your email to download,” this is the whole product.
The honest caveats, all verified: there is no web dashboard (aliases are managed in the DDG browser’s Passwords menu or via per-email banners), initiating a brand-new thread from an alias needs a workaround address format rather than a compose box, and the SPF catch — if your forwarding address lives on a unique domain without an SPF record, replies are not supported. On a plain Gmail destination, none of that touches you.
When the paid stack earns its keep
Two cases, and only two, reliably beat the free setup:
- A professional identity you control. When the address is business infrastructure — invoices, a domain on your business cards — you need your own domain with a catch-all, not @duck.com. That starts at SimpleLogin Premium ($36/yr, unlimited domains) or Proton Mail Plus ($2.49/mo first-year promo, renews $47.88/yr; 1 custom domain, catch-all included).
- Content-sensitive correspondence. When the body of the mail is the secret — legal, medical, source-protection work — you need an encrypted provider, with the metadata honesty that comes with it: even then, the subject line and routing data leak unless the other side plays along. Read Your Encrypted Email Leaks Its Subject Line before paying anyone for “end-to-end.”
Spam and marketing → $0: DDG aliases plus inbox filters. Professional domain → $36/yr: SimpleLogin Premium with your own domain. Sensitive content → a paid encrypted inbox — and check the metadata traps first, because that is what you are still leaking.
The €1 escape hatch
The day free stops being enough, the first paid step is not a $60/yr suite. Mailbox.org Light is €1/month (annual billing only) — 2GB, 3 aliases, and full OpenPGP on every plan: Guard, Mailvelope, their own HKPS key server. It is the cheapest real PGP mailbox we could verify, and it exists precisely for this moment — when you want out of the ad-supported inbox without committing to the full stack. The complete per-year pricing for every tier above it is in The Real Cost of a Private Inbox, and all verified limits — sending caps, alias bandwidth, metadata posture — are in the Email privacy hub.