Proton Mail
Proton AG · email privacy · reviewed by Stan K. · Source: data snapshot · data as of 2026-11-13
Zero-access encrypted mail where the subject line is encrypted at rest — unique among PGP providers — and the only encrypted inbox in this comparison with IMAP via Bridge.
#2 of 10 in Email Privacy
ToolScore breakdown — why 86/100
10 criteria × 10 points. Low pillars are visible on purpose — that's the point of a score you can audit. Methodology →
What it does well
- ▸Subject line gets zero-access encryption at rest — unique among PGP providers in this comparison
- ▸The only encrypted provider that publishes real sending caps (150/day · 50/hour on Free; 100 recipients per email on Plus) and the only one with IMAP — Bridge is included on Plus
- ▸150 messages/day is the most generous published free sending cap in the table
- ▸One subscription covers inbox + 10 addresses + catch-all on your own domain
- ▸Free tier is genuinely usable: 1GB Mail grown via the onboarding checklist, plus 10 hide-my-email aliases
Where it costs you
- ▸$2.49/mo is a first-year promo — the renewal is $47.88/yr ($3.99/mo) and the page never shows $3.99 as an entry price
- ▸Only 1 custom domain on Plus (Tuta gives 3, StartMail Business unlimited)
- ▸The daily sending cap for paid tiers is not published — only the per-email recipient ceiling (100) is
- ▸Free caps that bite first: 3 folders / 3 labels / 1 filter, and @pm.me is closed to new free accounts
Hidden traps — the stuff the pricing page doesn't say
$2.49/mo ($29.88) renews at $47.88/yr = $3.99/mo. The pricing page shows no $3.99 entry price — if you budget the promo number, you are budgeting less than two-thirds of the real cost.
On Free, Proton counts each recipient as a separate message: 150/day and 50/hour means a 15-person group mail exhausts the day in 10 sends. Paid lifts the per-message ceiling to 100 recipients, but the paid daily cap is not published at all.
The short receive-only @pm.me address is no longer available to new free accounts — existing users keep it, new ones need a paid plan to activate it at all.
3 folders, 3 labels and 1 filter are the organizing limits that bite first on Free — long before you feel the 1GB storage ceiling.
Know the limits before you pay: read the traps above, then decide with eyes open.
Visit official siteAffiliate link where available — never affects the score.
- official Proton Mail pricing (official, checked 2026-11-13) verified
- official Proton sending limits — 150/day, 50/hour, 100 recipients (official) verified
- official Proton @pm.me addresses — closed to new free accounts (official) verified
Data as of 2026-11-13. Prices and limits change monthly — report anything stale. How we verify: methodology.
Closest alternatives
PGP-encrypted alias forwarding with published daily send caps — and a Free tier where the 10MB/month
The subject line is end-to-end encrypted inside Tuta's own post-quantum protocol — the best metadata
Unlimited aliases, unlimited custom domains, replies and reverse-alias sending — the alias service w
Proton Mail review
In-depth analysis · last updated 2026-11-13
The reference encrypted inbox
Proton Mail is the provider every other encrypted mailbox in this comparison is measured against, and two published facts explain why. It is the only one that discloses its sending caps (150/day and 50/hour on Free, 100 recipients per email on Plus) — everyone else in the table leaves that cell as "—". And it is the only PGP provider whose subject line is encrypted at rest: zero-access storage means the envelope, not just the body, is opaque to the provider. With outsiders the usual PGP rules apply — the subject travels as plaintext in transit, because OpenPGP (RFC 3156) simply does not cover the Subject header.
The economics — read the renewal, not the promo
Plus is advertised at $4.99/mo monthly, with a first-year promo of $2.49/mo ($29.88). The number that matters is the renewal: $47.88/yr = $3.99/mo, which the pricing page never shows as an entry price. For that you get 15GB shared between Mail and Drive, 10 addresses, one custom domain with catch-all, and Bridge — the only IMAP access in the encrypted category. The Free tier (scored 80 in our hub) is the most generous published free deal here: $0, 500MB grown to 1GB Mail via the onboarding checklist (plus 5GB Drive), 10 hide-my-email aliases, and 150 messages/day — but every recipient counts as a separate message, and the @pm.me receive-only address is now closed to new free accounts.
Real limits
The published caps are honest but layered: Free gives 150/day with a 50/hour ceiling; Plus lifts the per-message recipient count to 100 — and the daily cap for paid tiers is not published. Organization limits arrive before storage limits on Free (3 folders, 3 labels, 1 filter). One domain with catch-all is included; Tuta's Revolutionary tier includes 3, StartMail's Business tier unlimited.
How the pillars land
Price/Value 9.5: effective $2.49/mo entry and $3.99/mo renewal for 15GB plus Bridge is the strongest value in the encrypted table. Clients & access 9.5: Bridge included — the only explicit IMAP "Yes" here. Metadata posture 9.5: subject encrypted at rest, zero-access, but body-only toward external recipients. Custom domains 8: one domain, catch-all included. Real limits 9: caps published that rivals keep dark, docked for the unpublished paid daily cap. Pricing transparency 8.5: publishes what nobody else publishes, but never displays the $3.99 renewal as an entry price. Support & docs sits at the neutral 5 — nothing support-related was verifiable from the official pages in this snapshot.
Verdict — BEST VALUE, 86/100
For most people shopping for an encrypted inbox, Proton Mail Plus is the default answer: published limits, standard-client access via Bridge, and the best at-rest metadata posture a PGP provider can offer. Pair it with an alias layer — that's the stack the hub recommends, and Proton also owns SimpleLogin (since 2022). Budget the $3.99 renewal, and if you're on Free, remember that one group mail to 10 people is 10 of your 150.