ToolScore

SimpleLogin

SimpleLogin (Proton) · email privacy · reviewed by Stan K. · Source: data snapshot · data as of 2026-11-13

Unlimited aliases, unlimited custom domains, replies and reverse-alias sending — the alias service where the fine print is shortest.

#1 of 10 in Email Privacy

Get SimpleLogin
Real price
$3/mo
freemium
Free tier
Yes
Premium is $36/year or $4 billed monthly (annual = $3.00/mo). Free tier: 10 aliases, 1 mailbox, unlimited band
Limits
9.5/10
$36/yr ($3/mo) or $4/mo monthly · Free: 10 aliases, replies work
Verdict
BEST VALUE
Premium: unlimited aliases, unlimited bandwidth, every forwarded email capped at 25MB (documented in the FAQ),

ToolScore breakdown — why 92/100

Price / Value
9.5
Real limits (storage · caps · bandwidth)
9.5
Clients & access (IMAP, apps)
8.5
Metadata posture
8.0
Custom domains
10.0
Feature set (aliases, PGP)
9.5
Track record
9.5
Ease of use
9.0
Pricing transparency
9.5
Support & docs
9.0

10 criteria × 10 points. Low pillars are visible on purpose — that's the point of a score you can audit. Methodology →

What it does well

  • ▸Unlimited aliases AND unlimited custom domains on Premium — the only service in this hub with both
  • ▸Replies work out of the box, even on the Free tier — unique among free alias plans
  • ▸Initiate new threads from any alias via reverse-alias (Premium)
  • ▸Downgrade-safe in writing: existing aliases keep forwarding after you cancel
  • ▸Open source and self-hostable — zero breaches on record since the 2022 Proton acquisition

Where it costs you

  • ▸Per-email size ceiling of 25MB — bandwidth is unlimited, message size is not
  • ▸Initiating (reverse-alias) is Premium-only; Free is receive-and-reply only
  • ▸Free tier tops out at 10 aliases and 1 mailbox
  • ▸Self-hosting trades every hosted limit for your own deliverability problem — a fresh IP starts with no reputation

Hidden traps — the stuff the pricing page doesn't say

medium risk25MB per-email cap under an 'unlimited bandwidth' headline

Bandwidth is genuinely unlimited, but every forwarded email is capped at 25MB (per the SimpleLogin FAQ). Large attachments die at the relay on Free and Premium alike.

low riskDowngrade keeps aliases but freezes creation at 10

Cancel Premium and existing aliases keep forwarding — but you can't create new ones past the Free tier's 10. If you're near the limit, create the aliases you'll need before cancelling.

medium riskThe forwarding server reads everything in plaintext

Like every alias service, SimpleLogin's forwarding server sees message content in plaintext — an alias hides your address from senders, not from the forwarder. Pair it with an encrypted inbox; that is exactly why Proton bought SimpleLogin in 2022.

Try SimpleLogin

Know the limits before you pay: read the traps above, then decide with eyes open.

Visit official site

Affiliate link where available — never affects the score.

What the advertised price hides
Premium is $36/year or $4 billed monthly (annual = $3.00/mo). Free tier: 10 aliases, 1 mailbox, unlimited bandwidth with a 25MB per-email cap — replies work even on Free. Self-hostable, so the hosted limits are hosted-plan limits only.
Sources & freshness

Data as of 2026-11-13. Prices and limits change monthly — report anything stale. How we verify: methodology.

Closest alternatives

SimpleLogin review

In-depth analysis · last updated 2026-11-13

The benchmark alias service

SimpleLogin is the value pick of the email-privacy hub, and the reason is structural: it is the only service where none of the headline features collapse into a footnote. Premium ($36/year or $4 billed monthly) buys unlimited aliases, unlimited custom domains, replies that work, and reverse-alias sending to start new threads. Every other alias service in our comparison gives up at least one of those four.

What the limits actually are

Bandwidth is unlimited — but each forwarded email is capped at 25MB, per the FAQ. That is the honest version of "unlimited": the constraint is per-message size, not volume, and it is documented rather than discovered. Custom domains are unlimited too, with 5 subdomains and 50 directories on top; no competitor matches that domain allowance.

The free tier is usable, not bait

SimpleLogin Free (scored 88 in our hub) gets 10 aliases on one mailbox with unlimited forwarding — and it is the only free alias tier we checked where replies work out of the box. What Free lacks is initiating: starting a new thread from an alias requires the Premium reverse-alias. The upgrade path is a genuine feature gap, not a crippled core.

The exit is designed in

Downgrade safety is written down: cancel Premium and every existing alias keeps forwarding; you simply can't create new ones past the Free limit of 10. Add the 2022 Proton acquisition (SimpleLogin is bundled with Proton Pass premium, zero breaches on record) and the stability question mostly answers itself. Both SimpleLogin and Addy.io are open source and self-hostable — a ~$5/mo VPS removes every hosted limit, but hands you DNS, backups and a fresh IP with zero deliverability reputation.

Verdict

92/100, BEST VALUE. Unlimited aliases plus unlimited domains plus working replies at $3/mo annual is the strongest limits-per-dollar in the alias category, and the free tier is good enough to stay on indefinitely. Just remember the 25MB per-email ceiling and that the forwarding server itself reads plaintext — pair it with an encrypted inbox.

From the insights